inventio: creative thinking about learning and teaching
     
Fall 2006   orange square    Issue 1, Volume 8       in this issue       past issues       about inventio       editorial board
     
horizontal blue bar
     
  Five Institutions Compare Programs in Teaching and Research in Information Technology: An Interim Report  

  by:
  Bill Israel

orange square  Introduction

Principals in technology across the curriculum programs from five institutions gathered at George Mason University in May 2005 to consider the varying approaches they had made.(2) The five institutions -- Claremont McKenna College, DePauw University, George Mason University, North Carolina State University, and The University of Massachusetts Amherst, differ as to size, mission, and organization.(3)

In brief, Claremont McKenna, Claremont, Calif., and DePauw, Greencastle, Ind., both are exclusively undergraduate, four-year baccalaureate institutions, whose students are primarily full-time and four-year matriculates, in institutions that are more selective, with few transfers in.  Both are small, highly residential campuses; and private, not-for-profit.

The three other institutions are each public universities. George Mason, the youngest of the three, is a comprehensive doctoral granting institution with “high” research activity, under the Carnegie guidelines.  North Carolina State has “very high” research activity with doctoral education focused primarily in science, technology and mathematics (STEM) fields.  The University of Massachusetts Amherst, like George Mason, is a comprehensive doctoral granting institution; like North Carolina State, with “very high” research activity in STEM fields, but in non-STEM fields, as well.  All three have substantial undergraduate enrollments; George Mason’s tend to be less residential than the other two.

The five institutions are compared as to the interim institutional categories of the Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching in Figure 1 (4).

To better compare the five programs, we review each as to its origins and direction, mission, orientation to the NRC FITness report as to teaching and research, and overall campus outcomes.(5)


© Copyright by Bill Israel. The right to make additional exact copies, including this notice, for personal and classroom use, is hereby granted. All other forms of distribution and copying require permission of the author(s).
 
     
 
previous page | next page
 
     
horizontal blue bar
     
      DoIT...supporting excellence in learning and teaching.
 
    Send questions and comments to:
 
    orange bullet  Lesley Smith, Managing Editor of inventio
    orange bullet  Robert Bernard, Assistant Editor of inventio